- Does it caption people talking in the room?
-
Yes, when you ask it to. By default it reads what your Mac plays and
the microphone stays closed. Choose the microphone in Listen To and
it captions the conversation in front of you instead, through the
Mac's microphone or whichever input Sound settings has; macOS asks
for the microphone the first time, and not before. With Translate To
and Show Both Languages on, the two of you can talk in two languages
and each read your own.
- Is this a replacement for CART or a human captioner?
-
No. It is speech recognition, so it makes mistakes, particularly on
names, jargon, crosstalk and heavy accents. For a medical appointment,
a legal meeting, a class you are graded on or anything else where
being wrong has a cost, a professional captioner or interpreter is the
accommodation and you are entitled to ask for it. This is for the rest
of the day, where nobody was ever going to provide one.
- Do I have to ask the host, or tell anyone I am using it?
-
No. It captions the audio your Mac plays rather than integrating with
any service, so nothing joins the meeting, nothing appears in a
participant list, and no host, admin or lecturer has to enable
anything. Nobody is told. Whether you disclose is your decision rather
than the software's.
- I already stream my Mac's audio to my hearing aids. Does this add anything?
-
Often, yes. Streaming fixes the path the sound takes, not how hard
the speech is: fast talkers, crosstalk and unfamiliar accents are
still fast talkers, crosstalk and unfamiliar accents once they arrive
in your ear. Captions over streamed audio is a common setup rather
than a redundant one. It reads the app's own audio stream rather
than your output device, so what you listen on is not part of the
picture and nothing about your pairing changes.
- What if a video has no subtitles or SDH at all?
-
That is the case it is for. Closed captions and SDH only exist where
somebody made them, which leaves out most internal training videos,
most conference recordings and most things a colleague records and
sends you. This captions the audio itself, so it does not matter
whether the file came with a subtitle track.
- Do the captions lag behind, like the ones in my meetings?
-
Less, but not never. It captions continuously as words arrive rather
than waiting for a finished sentence, and the newest word is drawn
dimmer until the model is sure of it, so you are reading along rather
than reading afterwards. It is still speech recognition: there is
some delay between a word being said and that word being readable,
and somebody speaking quickly will always be a little ahead of any
caption.
- Can I make the captions bigger and easier to read?
-
Yes. Box size, opacity, how many lines it holds and where it sits are
all settings, and the settings window previews them on the real
overlay rather than in a mockup. Hold Shift to keep it solid and drag
it where you want it; where you put it is remembered.
- Does it caption FaceTime and phone calls?
-
Anything that plays through an app on the Mac, which is FaceTime, a
WhatsApp or Signal desktop call, a number dialed through your Mac
and a voicemail played back. You read the other person and not
yourself, because it reads what the Mac plays rather than the
microphone. These are the calls with no captions button and no host
to ask, so they are often the first thing people try it on.
- Will it tell me who is speaking, or mark sounds like SDH does?
-
It can start a new caption box when the speaker changes, which is
optional and worth turning on for calls, but it does not put a name to
anyone. It does not mark non-speech sound at all: a voice detector
runs ahead of the recognizer so that music never turns into invented
lyrics, and the price of that is you get the speech and nothing about
what else was audible. If sound cues matter to you, this is the honest
gap against a proper SDH track.
- What happens when I miss a line?
- Hold ⌥ to rewind: the previous captions come back, as far back as you have set, and you can scroll through them or press ⌥F and type to find the one you want. It is deliberately short-term, and a long enough silence clears the stack: it is there to catch the sentence you just lost. When the audio stops, the app offers to save what was said as a transcript, and nothing is written to disk unless you do.
- Is there a per-minute or monthly cost?
-
No. It is free for 7 days and then $19 once, and the captions are
unlimited, because the model runs on your Mac and costs nothing to run. There are no minutes to buy
and no subscription, which matters more when captions are how you
follow everything rather than something you switch on occasionally.
- Does it need an internet connection?
-
Once, to fetch the model on first run. After that it runs entirely
offline, and the only requests it can still make are a daily check
for a newer version, which you can decline, and a monthly check of
your license key once you have one. Nothing you listen to is ever
sent anywhere.